Writing green claims for packaging and ads that stand up to scrutiny

Recycled cardboard product boxes and paper labels being checked on a packaging workbench

Environmental messages are everywhere on packaging and in advertising, and so is scepticism about them. In the UK the reference point for anyone writing or designing an eco claim is the Competition and Markets Authority's Green Claims Code. Its core test is whether the overall impression is accurate, and the CMA is clear that the impression comes from the words and from the colours, pictures and logos used. For designers, that means a green palette and a leaf icon can count as a claim in their own right, so they need the same evidence as the copy.

The six principles

The CMA published the Green Claims Code in September 2021 to help businesses meet their existing obligations under consumer law. The full guidance sets out six principles. Claims must:

  1. be truthful and accurate;
  2. be clear and unambiguous;
  3. not omit or hide important relevant information;
  4. make only fair and meaningful comparisons;
  5. consider the full life cycle of the product or service; and
  6. be substantiated.

None of these is complicated. The difficulty is that marketing materials are produced quickly, by several people, and the claim on the front of a box can drift away from the evidence in a spreadsheet somewhere.

Imagery is part of the claim

The guidance says the overall presentation of a claim, including the wording, logos and imagery used and anything left out, can make it misleading. It also notes that the visual presentation (images, logos, packaging and colours) is an important part of the overall presentation, as are labels and certifications used to support claims.

This has practical consequences for packaging and campaign design:

  • Nature imagery. Forests, oceans and wildlife on a product that has no particular environmental benefit can suggest one.
  • Home-made badges. A circular "eco" stamp designed in-house can look like an independent certification. If it is not one, do not dress it up as one.
  • Colour. Switching a range to green and kraft-brown while nothing about the product has changed invites the question of what the change is meant to say.
  • Icons without words. A recycling symbol on its own leaves people guessing which part is recyclable and where.

Turn vague words into specific ones

Broad terms such as "eco-friendly", "sustainable" and "green" are hard to substantiate because they suggest a benefit across the whole product and its life. The code's emphasis on clarity and the full life cycle pushes towards specific, checkable statements instead. Compare:

  • "Eco-friendly packaging" with "Box made from 100% recycled card. Recycle with household cardboard."
  • "Sustainable cotton" with a statement naming the actual standard or source, if you can evidence it.
  • "Better for the planet" with a clear comparison: better than what, measured how, and over which part of the product's life.

If a claim needs a long explanation to be accurate, put the key qualification next to it, not on a back panel or a separate web page. The CMA warns against hiding important information, and a short qualifier beside the claim does far more than a page reference.

Net zero and carbon neutral

The guidance singles out claims about net zero and carbon neutrality as terms consumers find difficult to understand, and says businesses should be clear about what they are doing and how. If a claim relies on offsetting rather than reducing emissions, say so plainly. If it refers to a future target, make the date and the scope clear, and avoid a design that presents a plan as an achievement.

Certification marks and third-party labels

Independent labels can strengthen a claim, but only if they are used as their owners intend. Reproduce the mark at the size and in the colours the scheme allows, keep it next to the product or material it actually covers, and check the licence is current before every reprint. A label from a scheme that certifies one ingredient should not sit on the front of the pack as though it applied to everything inside.

A sign-off routine for eco claims

  1. List every claim. Include headlines, body copy, icons, badges, colour stories and imagery that could imply a benefit.
  2. Attach evidence. For each item, note the document that supports it and who owns it.
  3. Check the whole life. Ask whether a claim about one part, such as the packaging, could be read as being about the whole product.
  4. Read it as a customer. Look at the pack at arm's length for three seconds. What did it tell you?
  5. Record the decision. Keep the evidence file with the final artwork so it can be found when packaging is reprinted.

The cost of getting it wrong has gone up

The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 has raised the stakes for breaches of consumer law. The CMA's guidance for businesses on pricing notes fines of up to 10% of turnover or £300,000, whichever is greater, for breaches of the price rules under that Act. Misleading environmental claims sit within the same body of consumer law, so a slogan that once might have led to a polite letter could now be expensive. Reprinting packaging is costly too.

Brand it honestly

An honest claim is often a better design brief than a vague one. "Refill pouch uses less plastic than our bottle" gives a designer something concrete to show. If you are building or refreshing a brand around sustainability, our article on brand identity on a small budget covers how to keep a visual system consistent, and planning copy and design together helps keep words and visuals telling the same story. For anything you are unsure about, read the CMA code in full or speak to a trading standards or legal adviser before artwork goes to print.

Enjoyed this? See more in the blog, or write for us.